SIRs Home

This page last updated

02/19/2008

Society of Independent Representatives

Google
Web www.sirs4quality.org

 

SIRs News Frequently Asked Questions About Field Services Industry Articles Industry Related Links Certification Q&A Exam Scheduling

Directory Listing Request Field Directory Mailing List Free 'Rep Needed' Ad Annual Convention Info Contact Info Copyright and Privacy Policy

Mold: Myth and Madness

by Mimi Norris 8-3-2002

Three some years ago, mold was a non-issue. It was so much of a non-issue that during an interior property inspection, I personally spent over an hour detailing the layout of a severely mold infested property with little thought other than to record the condition on the final report. The client called wanting to know what the problem was and why I had stated "possible health threat" on the report. I had to explain that, here in Cleveland, Ohio a substance being referred to as "black mold" was on the news and was being blamed for the deaths of several infants. I further explained that this property was worse than any that had been shown on the news as far as the total area covered. The news had shown bits of mold on the walls and some more mold on the underlying studs. This property, that I spent over an hour in, unprotected, had mold everywhere - up the walls, across the floors, on the ceiling - it was a veritable piece of mold in and of itself. This had to be a health threat and I thought I should alert the lender.

Today, mold is the hottest issue around, not only for the field servicing industry but for society in general. Not only is mold a hot issue, it is an extremely litigious issue with multi-million dollar lawsuits flashing the news headlines with more frequency than defendants care for it to be. We see mold seminars frequently being announced not only for mere educational purposes but also for preservation mechanics to learn how to abate or remediate the mold from vacant properties. There is a veritable band-wagon going by with every other preservation mechanic jumping on it. HUD, one of the largest loan guarantors, generally will not accept properties with mold in them. Likewise, Fannie Mae has stated each property will be assessed on a case-by-case scenario to determine if the property should be abated or sold as is. This leaves lenders and servicing companies jumping to have the properties abated within a reasonable cost so that the properties under their ownership or care can be converted to the guarantor and the loan guarantee paid off.

How serious is the mold problem for vacant properties? Several servicers have stated that their inventory records show an increase from as low as 3% to as high as 70% this year over last year of properties with mold in them. This means that last year, as few as 3 out of 100 properties were reported as having mold. This year as many as 70 properties out of 100 are reported as having mold. Could it be that awareness of the issue has revealed more properties having a problem or is it a monetary issue? One seminar ad circulating states that millions will be spent on mold abatement this year! No doubt, a preservation mechanic that offers remediation services may see more mold than a preservation mechanic that does not offer remediation services. As an inspector, I find very few properties having mold. However, now that I am aware that mold is an issue, I do look more carefully for it when inside a property. I also take more health precautions for my own safety and I would no longer enter a severely mold infested property without some form of protection.

Mold is natural in our environment. It exists in the air around us and is a living organism. Mold is not a problem in most homes that have proper ventilation and adequate protection from water/ moisture. Mold does not just grow out of control all by itself. There is usually some event that triggers abnormal growth. That event could be a leak in the structure (such as a roof leak) or a water entry point (such as a broken plumbing line) or a lack of care (such as a sump pump not working because the electric service has been disconnected). Given the moist and unventilated environment mold needs to grow, in a vacant property mold can rapidly grow out of control. Once mold is discovered, it must be appropriately addressed.

Addressing mold must be done in stages with the first stage being to address the conditions which allowed the mold to grow in the first place. In the instance of vacant properties, this would be repairing the roof leak, repairing the plumbing lines, or restoring the electric service and ensuring the sump pump is operational. Without the cause of the moisture being addressed, mold will re-grow and any steps taken to abate or remediate will be pointless.

Once the causing factor is remedied, the second stage to addressing mold would be to dry out the property. Remove the excess moisture from the area and the structure itself. This could be as simple as running a dehumidifier for a day and mopping up the water on the floor if the event is immediately attended to (within a day of occurrence). In severe instances and with most vacant properties where the event has occurred weeks and sometimes months prior to being addressed, running several industrial dehumidifiers for weeks may be needed to thoroughly dry the structure which has absorbed water/moisture over a prolonged period of time. Without the excess moisture being removed, mold will only re-grow regardless of any other steps taken to remediate or abate it.

Only after the causing factor and the subsequent moisture are addressed can you begin to abate and remediate the mold problem. At this point, it is necessary to have a knowledgeable contractor remove any damaged construction from the property. A tear-out of porous construction material (drywall, wallpaper, particle board, pressed wood, damaged paneling) is required because mold grows into the material with roots, just like a plant. You can think of mold like a dandelion flower. Those notorious little yellow flowers that plague most lawns! The dandelion roots go down into your lawn and requires a special tool to cut the root out to ward off the re-growth. Mold is similar to this. You have to remove the roots! As mold roots are microscopic, the only way to remove most of the root is to dig down into the construction material, by means of a tear-out, to accomplish the removal. A knowledgeable contractor will know how extensive the tear-out needs to be.

Once the tear-out is accomplished, the remaining areas need to be brush cleaned with a special anti-microbial cleanser to effectively kill and remove surface mold from the studs or framing of the property. This needs to now dry. Once dry, a special encasement sealer needs to be applied - not just ordinary paint! The sealer used has anti-microbial treatment in it and will assist in the determent of mold re-growth. As a lender, you can decide whether re-building is needed to make your property market ready or convey condition. In a basement area, it may be wiser to leave an unfinished basement. In a living area, it is probably best to restore the construction to a readily usable living area.

The last stage in mold remediation is to maintain a proper conditioned atmosphere so mold will not re-grow. This means that you need to keep the electric service on if due to sump pump damage. Keep the water off in situations where a broken plumbing line was the cause. Ensure that the roof will not leak again by repairing fully the damaged area: replace the roof if it is completely bad. Tarps are only temporary measures and will not hold up for the extensive time frames that most properties remain vacant.

While all the above information may be helpful to you, it does not tell you why you want to take all the appropriate steps. The following photographic documentation will assist in the "why" of it. Which also leads us to the "what" of it. What are you receiving for your money? In this instance, this property required electric restoration to operate a sump pump in a high water table area. The sump pump was not operating and water backed up into the lower level of the property. The carpet was saturated and mold growth/ mushrooms were evident upon securing. Details of the situation were reported to the lender and mold remediation services were hired prior to the water problem being corrected. The end result was that the property remained mold infested regardless of any abatement services that were performed.

Error # 1 - Electric was not restored prior to remediation.

Error #2 - The property was not dried out at all or at least not sufficiently.

Error #3 - The wet carpet was not removed prior to remediation.

Error #4 - A detailed plan of remediation was not given or performed (a reliable and recognized contractor was not hired for the job).

Result - The lender believed the property was ready for conveyance when in fact the property was not conveyable.

The following photography is dated and actual record of the progressive changes at the property.

Clicking each photo will enlarge it in a new window.

at initial secure

at electric restoration/ carpet removal

at conveyance secure

comments

photo of the den area prior to any services being performed. the carpet is wet due to the electric being off and the sump pump not operating

photo of the den before the carpeting was removed. mushrooms are growing out of the carpet, paint is dripped onto the carpet. the carpet is water saturated.

photo of the den area where paint is slopped on the walls and dripping over the trim work. mold can be seen leaking through the paint job. if an encapsulator had been used there would be no leaking of the mold stain

On secure the carpet was wet and mushrooms growing. The paint was neat as is normal. At electric restoration, the carpet was still wet and mushroomed but the walls displayed signs of having been painted. At convey, the walls had obviously been "abated" and paint is dripped. There are still signs of mold.

photo of the bathroom prior to any services being performed - mold can be seen on the wall and vanity door

no photo

this area

this date

photo of the interior of the vanity which is covered in mold

At secure, the bathroom vanity displayed mildew and possible mold growth. At convey, the vanity displayed serious mold growth - after abatement services were rendered. The vanity is pressed wood and should have been removed.

photo of the divider wall prior to any services being performed. mold is developing due to the sump pump not working

photo of the divider wall with mold all over growing up from the floor due to the water problem

photo of the basement divider wall which has been slopped with paint. mold is growing above the painted area and leaking through the painted area

At initial secure, mold is running up the wall from the floor. At electric restoration, the mold has advanced. By conveyance, the area had been "abated" of mold. Mold was growing above the "abated" area.

photo of the basement floor prior to any services being performed. it is wet and mold can be seen developing on the walls in the background

photo of the basement flooring - still wet and moldy

photo of painted wall area - paint is slopped on and dripped all over floor. corners are not painted thoroughly and mold can be seen through the paint as well as on areas that are not painted

The west wall and floor show signs of mold at both the initial and electric restoration dates. By conveyance, the area had been "abated". Mold is advanced beyond the white area and bleeding through what should have been a sealant paint.

photo of the bathroom wall prior to any services being performed. mold is clearly developing and evident by the black spottings

no photo

this area

this date

photo of the bathroom where paint can be seen all over the flooring

The bathroom wall is displaying signs of mold at initial securing. At conveyance, the door is 1/2 painted, the mold is bleeding through what should have been an encapsulator and sealer. No bleed through should have occurred.

no photo

this area

this date

photo of the area between the furnace duct and the hot water tank where mold is clearly evident

photo of the area between the furnace duct and the hot water tank - this area is infested with mold and was not even noticed by the abating contractor

In this area, behind the furnace and hot water tank, mold was evident at both the electric restoration and the conveyance inspections. The mold has obviously progressed. This area was completely overlooked by the abatement contractor.

photo of the hallway prior to any services being performed. the carpet is so wet that the securing contractors footprints are leaving wet impressions

photo of the hallway where mushrooms are growing out of the wet carpet and mold is evident on the walls and woodwork

photo of the hallway area - paint is all over the floor, mold is growing as mushrooms, after the abatement

At Initial securing, the hallway carpet is wet. At electric restoration, the carpet clearly has mushroom growth. By conveyance, the area is splattered with paint, mushrooms and mold.

photo of the stairwell prior to any services being performed - the area is blackened with mold

no photo

this area

this date

photo of the stairwall - mold continues to grow through the paint. proof that an encapsulator was not used. Paint can be seen dripped and slopped all over.

The stairwell at initial secure is discolored. At conveyance, the discoloration is still evident but obviously has had "abatement" treatments. Mold can be seen growing through what should have been a sealer/encapsulator paint treatment.

 

Steps you can take to avoid "being taken".

In the field service industry, most "owners" are lenders that sit at office desks states away from where the property is located. The lender never sees the property; cannot personally oversee the services being performed; and must rely on others to maintain and report conditions at properties. Being physically distant has obvious disadvantages and leaves the lender susceptible to hiring sub-standard services such as those shown above. But distance is not an excuse. You can monitor the services you hire by employing certain policies for oversight and Quality Control.

 

1. When there are reports of a mold situation, address the causing factor first.

2. Once proof is in hand that the causing factor has been addressed, secure the services of an inspector to detail the damage.

3. Check the abatement companies scope to ensure the list of services closely matches the damage the inspector has detailed.

  • All remediation services should include a HVAC duct service itemization as this area always accumulates dirt during use which will readily absorb moisture and be a breeding ground for mold.

  • The scope should follow the New York City Guidelines for Mold Abatement. As there are no current laws governing this issue, this step is the most important when hiring a contractor.

4. Check the credentials of the abatement company:

  • Appropriate training from a recognized institute.

  • Appropriate insurance coverage - most general liability and "errors & omissions" will not cover mold abatement/remediation services. To protect yourself from liability issues, Pollution Insurance is appropriate.

  • Request proof of the above.

5. Before and After Photos Do NOT Justify Proof!!!!! Treat all remediation services as you would an insured loss.

Require Loss Draft Inspections.

  • An independent inspection should occur when the tear-out has been completed and the mold has been completely removed.

  • An independent inspection should occur at completion of dry-out. A QC Inspector can provide moisture readings of the structure to attest to the dried-out state.

  • An independent inspection should occur when the encapsulation has been completed.

  • Additional independent inspections can be requested if re-construction is to be performed.

At a Minimum - Require Before, DURING, and After Photos. Emphasis should be on the During - Maximum photos or a Video documentation should be requested to prove that the work was actually performed.

During photos should detail:

  • the tear-out

  • the scrubbing in progress

  • the encapsulation in progress

  • the reconstruction in progress

  • Each step of the scope should be accompanied by appropriate photographs.

6. Require dated receipts for both the anti-microbial cleanser and the anti-microbial sealer. These are specialty products that generally would not be "in stock" for the typical contractor. Require proof that the contractor purchased these products for your project.

7. Require a Notarized Affidavit that the inspector who is actually performing inspections on the progress has no vested or financial interest in the contractor company that is performing the abatement services. This would assure you that a true "third-party" completed the oversight on your behalf.

 

These steps are not absolute guarantees that the services will be performed accordingly. However, the few dollars spent on additional inspections or photographs will be an added measure protecting your investment in the services being performed. An extra few dollars is a small price to pay when thousands are presently being spent on services that may not be properly performed. Inspectors who complete Loss Draft Inspections can cite numerous instances where fire and water restorations services supposedly completed may appear to be so in photographs but during physical "all five senses" inspections, water, mildew and/or smoke can be detected as still present within the property. The "all five senses" inspection is the additional security device readily available to those hiring abatement services.

 

Resources used to complete article:

"National Mold Abatement Seminar" March 26, 2002, Vienna, VA

"S.I.R.s First Annual Convention" July 13, 2002, Columbus, OH

Abatement Technologies

American Indoor Air Quality Council

Association of Specialist in Cleaning and Restoration

Center for Disease Control

Claims Magazine

Chlorine Bleach and Mold Clean Up

Indoor Air Quality Association

IAMRS (Now - Environmental Education Foundation)

Mold Update

New York City Department of Health and Mental Hygiene

TMC Group

US Environmental Protection Agency

University of Minnesota: Environmental Health and Safety

 

 

 

Read Other Articles on SIRs

The Industry Standard of Securing and Preservation

Freeze Damages Found US Nationwide

The Problem with HUD's Requirement to Clean Toilets prior to Winterization - (warning may be graphically offensive)

Recap of HUD Meeting in Washington, D.C. April 25th, 2007

 

Available Courtesy of FEMA

Mold and Mildew: Cleaning Up Your Flood-Damaged Home
 

if you would like a copy of the above information to save, it is available in Adobe Click Here

 

About SIRs • Standards and Canon of Ethics • Seal of Quality • Membership Benefits • Requirements and Application • Member Roster • Members Only • Site Map • What's New

SIRs News • Frequently Asked Questions • About Field Services • Industry Articles • Industry Related Links • Certification Q&A • Exam Scheduling

Directory Listing Request • Field Directory • Mailing List • Free 'Rep Needed' Ad • Annual Convention Info • Contact Info • Copyright and Privacy Policy